Our Menu
Tally's offers a cash discount
Fan Favorites
House-roasted turkey, cheddar, bacon, avocado, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato. Bread Choice: Rosemary ciabatta or sourdough ciabatta
House-roasted turkey, stuffing, cranberry mayo on homemade cranberry bread, grilled and served warm
Oven-baked ham, warm brie, sliced green apple, Dijonese, served on grilled sourdough ciabatta
House-roasted turkey, cheddar, bacon, mayo, lettuce, tomato. Bread Choice: Rosemary ciabatta or sourdough ciabatta
Homemade chicken salad with pecans and craisins on a freshly baked seven-grain croissant
Roast turkey, melted Swiss, coleslaw, 1000 Island dressing on grilled marble rye
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, spinach, balsamic glaze on grilled rosemary ciabatta
Shaved corned beef, melted Swiss, sauerkraut, 1,000 Island dressing on grilled marble rye
Wraps
Wrap Options (applies to all wraps):
White
Spinach
Gluten-Free +$2.00
Lettuce, Parmesan, homemade croutons. Add Chicken (choose grilled or crispy): +$3.75
Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, choice of blue cheese or ranch. Chicken Style: choose grilled or crispy
Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, bacon, choice of honey mustard, ranch, or mayo. Chicken Style: choose grilled or crispy
Lettuce, carrot, cucumber, peppers, cabbage, oranges, toasted almonds, spicy peanut dressing. Add Chicken (choose grilled or crispy): +$3.75
Mixed vegetables. Mixed greens, onion pickle olives peppers cucumber tomato carrot cabbage banana peppers
Chicken, red onion, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, chopped and tossed in chipotle mayo. Chicken Style: choose grilled or crispy
Chicken, provolone, red onion, avocado, crispy bacon, garlic mayo, served in a toasted wrap. Chicken Style: choose grilled or crispy Hummus +$3.50 Cheese +$0.85 Chicken (choose grilled or crispy) +$3.75
Salads
All salads start with a mix of artisan greens, including tomato, cucumber, carrot, cabbage, green & red pepper, and homemade croutons.
Our traditional salad base with all the veggies
Grilled Chicken $3.75
Crispy Chicken $3.75
Egg Salad $4.25
Chicken Salad $4.25
Tuna Salad $4.25
Cape Cod Chicken Salad (with craisins and pecans) $4.50
Hummus $3.50
Mixed artisan greens, shredded Parmesan, homemade croutons. Add Chicken (choose grilled or crispy): $13.25
Mixed greens, carrots, cabbage, peppers, tomatoes, cucumbers, homemade croutons, shredded cheddar, craisins, toasted walnuts with a side of apple cider vinaigrette
Garden salad with cheddar and crispy bacon. Chicken Style: choose grilled or crispy
Garden salad with oranges, toasted almonds, spicy peanut dressing. Add Chicken (choose grilled or crispy): $13.50
Garden salad with cheddar, spicy buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese. Chicken Style: choose grilled or crispy
Kale, shaved Brussels sprouts, broccoli, mixed greens, Parmesan, cashews, homemade croutons. Add Chicken (choose grilled or crispy): $13.50
Kale, shaved Brussels sprouts, broccoli, mixed greens, goat cheese, green apples, crumbled bacon. Add Chicken (choose grilled or crispy): $13.70
Extra Bacon $2.00
Avocado $1.75
Cheese $0.85
Dressing $0.85
Sandwiches
Bread Options (featuring Botto’s Bakery): White | Wheat | Multigrain | Marble Rye | Gluten-Free Wrap +$2.00
Vegetable Choices (choose 2 included): Lettuce | Onion | Carrot | Red Peppers | Green Peppers | Tomato | Pickle | Banana Peppers | Cucumber | Extra Veggies +$0.50 each
House-roasted, hand-carved turkey
Homemade chicken salad with roasted chicken breast
Freshly made egg salad
House-baked, hand-carved ham
We use the best tuna! All white albacore mixed only with mayo, salt and pepper served on your choice if bread with you choice of two veggies.
Bacon, lettuce, tomato
Turn Any Sandwich into a Wrap +$1.50
Cheese (Cheddar, Swiss, American, Provolone)+$0.85
Bacon +$2.00
Avocado +$1.75
Extra Veggies +$0.50 each
Served all day
Breakfast
Egg and choice of cheese, served on a grilled English muffin
Wrap comes with 2 eggs and choice of cheese
Bacon +$2.00
Sausage +$2.00
Ham +$2.00
White
Wheat
Multigrain
Marble Rye
Sourdough Ciabatta +$1.25
Rosemary Ciabatta +$1.25
Croissant +$1.65
Avocado $1.75
Tomato $0.50
Spinach $0.50
Onion $0.50
Peppers $0.50
Chipotle Mayo
Hot Sauce
Ketchup
Mayo
Salsa
Sriracha
Sauce on the side + $0.85
Plain, Everything, Asiago
Toasted or Not Toasted
Plain Cream Cheese or Veggie Scallion
Smashed avo on toasty bakery bread
White wheat multi grain or marble the
Add an egg +$1.25
Add fresh spinach, tomato and balsamic glaze
Add an egg + $1.25
Gluten free pastry available upon request.
Fruit, yogurts, pastry 24 hours.
Casseroles 48 hours preferred.
Breakfast Catering
Serves 10+
Serves 24+
With toasted nuts, fresh berries, low-fat vanilla yogurt | Gluten-free granola for +$$
Whole or cut in 1/2 (half price). Bacon, ham, sausage, avocado, tomato, cheddar. Gluten-free wraps available.
Cut in half. With cream cheese, butter, peanut butter.
Plain, asiago, everything.
Plain cream cheese or veggie scallion.
With spinach, red onion, tomatoes cream cheeses and bagels.
Serves 12; approx.18 pieces. Assorted scones, breads, muffins, coffee cake, etc | *We always send a few gluten-free.
Serves 18.
Flavors: Blueberry Berry, Choc. Chip.
Sliçes of our pumpkin, banana, or lemon.
Serves 12 | Gluten free casserole available upon request.
Serves 12
Serves 12
A combo of fresh fruit, mini yogurt parfaits, hard boiled eggs and homemade pastry.
These are made in muffin cups and are great for gluten-free options. Bacon/cheddar, ham/feta, roasted red pepper, 3-cheese, spinach/bacon/cheeze.
Apple, Cran, OJ, V8, Water, Sparkling.
Serves 6-8 | 10 oz cups/lids/stirrers/cream/sugar/stevia. Hot Water, Reg. Flavor, Decaf.
Plates, napkins, forks, spoons.
Tallys offers delicious crowd-pleasing options for any event. We use the freshest ingredients, and our self-serving platters are creative, visually appealing, accommodating of dietary needs, and of the highest quality. Our fruits and veggies arrive that day, our cheeses are cut by hand, our turkey, ham, and pastry are baked here, and our breads come from a local bakery. We aim for a higher standard; we want to stand out.
Tally's specializes in helping you customize your event to fit your needs. For example, if you have 15 people at your event, you won’t need 2 large platters(40 pieces), so we customize, and we do 30 pieces. We want your event to be a success and, above all, for you to be proud of the food you served. We work with you to make choices we think will help you achieve your goals.
Menu
Our sandwich platters are a combination of our best-selling wraps, ciabattas, and freshly baked croissants. Our largest platter holds 20 pieces. A piece equals a ½ sandwich. Each piece is $7.00
We always include 2 vegetarian pieces on all of our sandwich trays, and they are flagged with a toothpick. We can also offer gluten-free wraps upon request. We have smaller-size platters available, which can be ordered by the piece. For example, a small gathering might want a large platter and an additional small platter with just 10 pieces. We can customize your order.
Fresh crunchy mixed greens, shredded carrot, cabbage, cucumber, red and green bell peppers and tomatoes make up our garden salads.
Popular dressings, pick 2: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Apple Cider Vinaigrette, Caesar.
Garden Salad $3.00 p/p #25 $62.50 #50 $125.00 #75 $187.50 #100 $250.00
*We also offer:
Caesar Salad $3.50 p/p
Power Caesar $4.50 p/p
Harvest Salad with cheddar, craisins and pecans $4.25 p/p
Killer Kale, $4.60 p/p
And more from our menu
*We often deconstruct our specialty salads serving the toppings in separate bowls to account for any food allergies**
Cali Club Ciabatta - House-roasted turkey, cheddar, avocado, bacon, chipotle mayo.
Cape Cod Chicken Salad - Chicken salad with craisins & pecans on a 7-grain croissant.
Mediterranean Rosemary Ciabatta - Our veggie option with fresh mozzarella, spinach, roasted red pepper, and balsamic glaze.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap - Crispy Buffalo chicken, ranch, cheddar, lettuce, tomato.
Baked Ham Club - Hand-carved ham, cheddar, bacon, honey mustard.
Chicken Pesto Wrap - Grilled chicken pesto, lettuce, tomato, provolone.
The classic finger sandwiches with your favorite fillings on only the best Bottos rolls.
Tuna Salad, Egg Salad, Chicken Salad
Large Platter - 36 $74.95
Medium - 24 $49.95
Fresh berries, chunks of melon, slices of apple and pear. Surround hand-sliced cheeses and cheese spreads. We add crackers, naan or pita, and other crunchy favorites.
Small #25 $95.00, Medium #50 $150.00, #75 $250.00, #100 $300.00
Veggies of all shapes, sizes, and colors, artistically displayed with various dips that are whipped and dense so they hold on to the veggies.
Mini spoons and tongs are displayed to help guide the guests as they graze and keep the display hygienic.
Small #25 $65.00, Medium #50 $125.00, #75 $185.00, #100 $250.00
All of our desserts are made in-house. We have a variety of squares, and our chocolate chip cookies and Whoopie pies are our specialty.
Cookies - people love our cookies.
Full size: $2.25 or tray of 12 $28.95
PREMIUM VARIETY OF TALLYS MINIS BITE SIZE:
Whoopies, cookies, lemon and raspberry squares, peanut butter.
Krispies, blondies, *By the dozen minimum 3 dozen ( estimate 2-3 per person)*
Small Tray (36 minis) $44.95
Medium (66 minis) $79.95
Large (100 minis) $112.95